My "magical realism" unit is fun and intriguing, because the settings of the texts are familiar (the real world) but the author has added extraordinary elements. Many students would recognize the use of magical realism in media and literature from their childhood (i.e. E. B. White's use of anthropomorphism in Stuart Little), which would help them become more engaged in the topic. The average ability students in my class will benefit from these texts in a variety of ways, because each text enhances the unit in its own unique fashion. The Heartbreak Soup: Love and Rockets graphic novel and the "Ten Dreams" fine art gallery website are to help students to comprehend magical realism through impressive visuals. Magic(al) Realism; The New Critical Idiom is a higher level text that helps the students navigate through the historical context and cross-cultural significance of magical realism; it is also rich with vocabulary building opportunities that would benefit lower-higher ability students. Anansi Boys is a perfect example of a contemporary, fantasy author drawing inspiration from another genre (in this case, West African Folk Tales); reading this text exposes the students to a humorous, natural writing style and entertaining genre they can add to their "literary toolkit", and utilize when asked to do creative writing assignments and ace the reading portion of standardized tests. To help each student recognize the plot development of each text, I've added the interactive graphic organizer "Story Map" as an after reading activity; this can be used as a class or in a group to start, but eventually the student will be able to use the organizers independently. The assessment for this unit would be a multi-genre project where the students apply all they've learned about magical realism into art pieces, writing, music, or any other medium they can find.
Gaiman, N. (2006). Anansi Boys. New York: Harper Collins
Flesch-Kincaid Index: 5.2
This novel is a wonderful read that kept me engaged from beginning to end.The story begins when Charlie "Fat Charlie" Nancy's father, Mr. Nancy, dies at a karaoke bar. The reason everyone calls the protagonist Fat Charlie is because his father gave him the embarrassing nickname in his youth, and it stuck. Most of the novel takes place in London, but Fat Charlie does return to his childhood home of Florida for his father's funeral. While in Florida, he comes across a family friend that informs Fat Charlie that his father was the trickster god Anansi, and that he has a brother named Spider that inherited their father's god-like powers. These powers include being able to disguise himself as other people, walk into photographs, etc. When Spider comes into Fat Charlie's life, utter chaos ensues: Spider successfully woos and falls in love with Rosie, Fat Charlie's fiancee', and he is the reason Fat Charlie is framed for the embezzlement schemes of his employer, Grahame Coats. More gods, ghosts and witches help to make Fat Charlie and Spider's adventure in the novel suspenseful and hilarious.
This book is 384 pages long, but I would like the students to read it in its entirety. Acknowledging the problem that many students home environments may not be conducive to effective reading, independent reading in class and at home, reading as a class and listening to the audio book version of the text, would make it possible to complete the novel in a few weeks. I would engage the students in a Directed Reading-Thinking Activity to get the most out of the text. Because it is estimated to be readable for at a 5th grade level, I would want to introducing the history of West African folktales (particularly the role of the spider Anansi, the trickster god), asking the students to predict what the novel may be about, discussing Gaiman's use of magical realism and extending the text into a multi-genre project to demonstrate their comprehension of the novel in an original way.
Bowers, M.A. (2004). Magic(al) Realism (The New Critical Idiom). New York: Routledge
Flesch-Kincaid Index: 19.2 (high estimate due in part to German and Hispanic multi-syllabic names and terms)
This text answers the questions "Where did magical realism come from and how does it vary cross-culturally?" There were three turning points in the development of magical realism: 1920s Germany, 1940s Central America and Latin America around 1955. Even though it is studied mostly in the context of literature, German art critic Franz Roh actually "coined the term that is translated as 'magical realism' to define a form of painting that differs greatly from its predecessor (expressionist art) in its attention to accurate detail...and the representation of the mystical non-material aspects of reality." (p. 9) Alejo Carpentier, a French-Russian Cuban diplomat and writer, is credited as the originator of Latin American magic(al) realism and the rest is history. There is a short glossary in the back of the book to help the students understand the historical terms Bowers uses, such as 'feminism' and 'Marxism, to help the students that may not have encountered those concepts in history class. The glossary also appropriately distinguishes between 'magic(al)' and 'marvellous' realism, for readers that may have difficulty comprehending the discussion of the concepts in the body of the text.
As informative as this book is, the writing is quite dense for high school juniors and seniors. I would do a Guided Reading Activity to help the students work through two more particularly interesting chapters, 'Cross-cultural Variants of Magical Realism' and 'Magic(al) Realism and Cultural Production'. These chapters will help keep the students engaged because they refer to
recognizable authors and cultural icons, like Roald Dahl and Harry Potter. After introducing the students to critical vocabulary terms and phrases found in the text (such as "ontology" and "sentimentality", I would shortly model how to read the text and let the students read silently. I would provide them with a reading guide and monitor the students'silent reading, as I am sure they will have questions about the author's syntax and concepts. This text would be used
to make a universal definition of magical realism that will be easy for the students to remember and understand.
Hernandez, G. (2007). Heartbreak Soup: Love and Rockets. Seattle: Fantagraphic Books
Flesch-Kincaid Index: 6.9
In the small town of Palomar, there is a multitude of stories that play out like a soap opera. There is a multitude of young and older characters that the reader can easily empathize with. This series of comics originally published by Hernandez as a graphic novelette, are in chronological order so the reader essentially sees the characters grow up throughout the collection. Palomar is in Central America, where the inhabitants speak Spanish and believe in the fantastical. The town is said to be plagued by spirits, which is the most prevalent use of magical realism in the text. One character, Heraclio, claims to see the ghost of young Toco waving at him from time to time; Pipo was once pushed off of an ancient statue on the outside of town, but witnesses claim no one was behind her. There characters fall in love with each other, and the friendships they've had since birth are tested at least once. There is nudity and swearing in the text, but nothing you can't find in an anatomy book or hear in everyday conversation.
For it's stunning visual and storytelling quality, I would use the appropriate chapters from Heartbreak Soup show how it has been applied to mediums other than narrative novels. If the students wanted to make a comic to put in their multi-genre project, they could use this as a model for developing a story with graphics. I would have the students independently read the chapters that demonstrate the use of magical realism, and then they would work in groups to answer stance questions about the text. Because there aren't many words, I would want the students to think critically about the images and text they are given. I would want them to answer Interpretation, Personal Reflection and Critical Analysis questions, such as "Compare the characters Luba and Chelo in the story", "How would you have reacted to seeing the ghost of your deceased neighbor waving to you?", or "How effective is Hernandez's use of illustrations with this selection?". These higher order thinking questions will help the students comprehend what they've read and to think critically , which is demanded of high school graduates when they enter the workforce.
"What is Magic Realism-An Introduction" (n.d.) Retrieved from http://www.tendreams.org/magic.htm
Readability Estimate: 13.1 (Flesch-Kincaid Index)
This website gives more historical context about the origins of magical realism, but this is from the framework of art. There are several chapters dedicated to magical realist art, including "The Roots of Magical Realism", "Magical Realism in the Americas" and "Contemporary Magic Realism". In each of the chapters, there are examples of the artists' works they are exploring in depth, which makes for a very engaging read. There are links to galleries that are full of magic realist examples from the artists of the Weimar Republic, America and Europe. The site is very organized and aesthetically pleasing, which makes it easy to get lost in the beautiful art and heaps of information very easily. Also, if students wanted to explore other movements in art, such as Metarealism and Symbolism, they could do so on the same site.
I would use this website to replace reading the beginning of Bowers text, because I was very frustrated while reading the many art references in the Magic(al) Realism: The New Critical Idiom without being able to see what she was actually talking about. The three galleries for the magic realism section of the website is a visual aid I would use for the students to compare and contrast the art to the magical realist writing we've read. I would also ask the students to compare and contrast the artists between the three galleries, so they could draw inferences as a class based on what they know about the socio-political atmosphere each piece of art came from. Ideally, I could collaborate with the Art and History departments in the school to make a (powerpoint) presentation about the different effects history had on the evolution of the magical realist art form before we read the Bowers text.
"Story Map" (2011) Retrieved from http://www.readwritethink.org/classroom-resources/student-interactives/story-30008.html
Readability Estimate: designed for K-12 students
"Read.Write.Think" is a website sponsored by the International Reading Association and the National Council of Teachers of English. There is a multitude of assets for English teachers and their students to help them share reading comprehension and writing strategies. In particular, the interactive "Story Map" is a handy tool for all students to consider the character, setting, conflict and resolution development throughout a story. There are also guiding questions to help students think about what they should be putting in each text box of the graphic organizer. The interactive nature of the organizer is engaging for a student of any ability level, and they can even print out their work after they're done; this makes it easier to compare their notes to the other readings they've done throughout the unit and share with the class in discussion.
While reading Anansi Boys, Heartbreak Soup, and any other short stories infused with magical realism, I would ask the students to complete this interactive story map to help monitor their comprehension. As I stated earlier, the students would find this graphic organizer a helpful tool to remember observations they've made about the magical realism texts we've read. I would also ask them to make cross-genre comparisons to see if the structure of a magical realist text resembles any other text they've read before; although it is dependent on how much we've studied in the curriculum so far and their prior knowledge from past English courses, I would hope they recognize that it is similar to surrealism, fantasy, and science fiction. Most importantly, I want the students to be able to confidently discern when a text, film, piece of art or animation is inspired by the principles of magical realism.